Another holiday weekend, another attempt to get us set for the mood with a blockbuster that was supposed to be timed well. One film this weeks is Antlers, a horror film with a poor record of push backs and advertising that has been lackluster, this supernatural epic might be limping at the box office this weekend. With a heavy hitter batting for the team, and the fact we can be surprised in this age of cinema, it was still worth a trip to check it out. Robbie K thanking you for taking a look with me as I review:
Movie: Antlers (2021)
- Director
- Writers
- Henry Chaisson(screenplay by)
- Nick Antosca(screenplay by)
- Scott Cooper(screenplay by)
LIKES:
The Filter:
It’s dark, it’s grey, and it’s perfect for the established setting that Antlers takes place in. Oregon’s rainy plateau and heavy forested areas hold much in the way of horror, but the added grey filter gives you the feeling of isolation in this small town. The creepy elements of the movie are amplified to an extent that you can feel the malice of the monsters and its victims in just about every shot. It’s that set up that is definitely the heavy lifting of the movie and like E.T. did in the 80s, immerses you into things at the just the right amounts.
The Artistic Approach to Horror:
Unlike many horror movies, Antlers took a less direct approach to horror and focused a lot more on the storytelling and build up instead of the jump scares. It works on a lot of levels, especially on the subject matter of myth, legends, and storytelling, primarily on how it effects a culture and grows into an entity of its own. That concept is very much like the beast in this film and they do a great job of circling the obvious source of the carnage before you ever get the real vision of what is doing this. Your Imaginate gets to sort of paint the idea of what this nightmare will look like, and that kind of storytelling is sometimes even better if done and timed right.
The Realism of the Entity:
Let’s face it, horror movies are seldom the most logical or realistic concepts given the themes they are often going for. Where we have ghosts with double standards, killers capable of transporting at the drop of a hat, and psychics who suddenly become gods, the absurdity of the movie monster has gone sky high in an attempt to be unique. Fortunately, Antlers grounds the nightmare to a reasonable level, creating a legend that actually has merit in being believable without ascending supervillain level. As the movie progresses, the actions of the antagonist grow to mirror that of the established legend and keep to moments that really do feel like it’s after you in the woods. Sure, it’s not the most cunning, exciting, or even most intense thing to grace your presence, but it works for the rules established and goes with the theme. Again, it’s the new atmosphere of the movie that works for me and seeing the other actors build up the horror, is the true level of creep factor that the movie does well.
The Characters:
Antlers again moves towards realism with the characters it portrays and how they have developed from their traumatic experiences. These aren’t individuals who have developed super powers or alternative identities, nor are they these cannon fodder sacrifices who are gussied up to the be the pretty face that we see get devoured. No, these characters are certainly realistic portraits of what people with rough past can be like in trying to cope back into real life. It leads to more engaging characters and potentially rooting for them finding a means to break through what lies in the woods. This drama element is very strong in the movie and the horror of how to handle all this pressure from the situation is really well done and truly a beast itself.
The Acting:
The movie’s staple is the acting, which is hands down incredible for a movie of this genre that normally does not rely on acting to make it better. Keri Russell is sensational in the lead, a balance of terror, depression, and trauma blending together into a lead that has both heart and brains to search for the answers. She does not tread into the overacting territory that much, keeping to the established responsibilities of her character and transitioning into the role quite well. I felt she really integrated herself in the character of Julia and engaging with all the characters in a natural manner. Jesse Plemons is a good character to bounce off of Russell’s more energetic nature, his blandness sort of establishing a character who compensates for his past in a more toned down way. A great glue to the town setting, Jesse’s range of acting is not as taxed as Russell’s, but does accomplish what he needs for advancing the plot and “mystery” element of the film. The winner for me is Thomas though, a young actor with a fantastic range and maturity in his performance as Lucas. A role that could have been much more limited, Thomas had a lot of adult elements to face in this movie as he tried to salvage his life situation to the best of his ability and portray someone drowning in drama and stress. I can’t say more without giving away plot elements, but his way of going through the stages of these breakdowns is super impressive for me. He somehow channels the wisdom of those decades older than him, but never lose the innocence of the child he is.
DISLIKES:
The Predictability
If you’ve seen the trailers or read the synopsis, you’ll be able to predict about 90% of the movie before it concludes. This diluted the horror element for me alongside the surprise twists this movie would have done well to have, but overall it’s not the worst limitation for me in this film.
The Lighting:
While certainly a wonderful element for establishing the mood and enhancing the creepy atmosphere, there are times the darkness can get in the way of the full scene and giving you the full picture of what lies out there in the woods. Antlers could use some lighting adjustments and slight tweaks to the mix, only going pitch black at a few times before enhancing the lighting to give more details. If watching at home, I recommend minimizing glare where you can, because it can really block the scene if you have too many lights on.
The Carnage:
This is not a movie for the faint of heart or stomach, as it does not pull the punches for showing the deaths and chaos of Antlers antagonist. Like the Walking Dead on steroids, this movie’s realistic approach means you will see some torture and tearing that might be too disturbing. An applause to the special effects and make up that I did not mention earlier, as they really do make props and accessories to bring the death to life. However, there is so much depressing mauling I can take at times before it grows a little too much for me.
The Character Development/Backstories
You can tell that this movie may have had more planned for diving into the psyche of our characters as they circle around the issue plaguing the town. An opening scene hints at the pasts of her demons, establishing the character’s struggles and what she had to do to survive. Other dialogue points to similar arcs for character like Joel, Lucas, and other characters that could have been engaging and useful tools for advancing the plot. Sadly, all those elements are practically absent, lost to brief shots and moments that sort of feel out of place without fully fleshing out the sequences and giving us those answers that still lay in mystery. Realism for deflecting gets some points, but what was the point of bringing it up if they did not have intentions to pursue it? This is the weakest element for me to be honest of the movie, and for one focusing on legend and taxing of your character, those origin and struggles internally need to be ironed out to deliver the character delivery you are looking for. This incomplete story telling really stands out in a lot of moments and takes away from the movie as a whole for me given the approaches they were taking.
More time with the monster:
It’s a unique approach seeing the thing’s progression to the screen, but it’s not until the last 15 minutes that you get the full picture of the antagonist. Again, I would have debuted the thing a little earlier and provided a more thrilling engagement than what I felt we got at the end. Though a bit tough, I think there was more that could have been done to finish the film, but the short run time and potential cuts means a director’s cut might be out there to fill in the gaps in the future.
The VERDICT:
Antlers is one of those movies that feels like a hybrid of an Indy horror and a Blockbuster for me. It’s got great visual style, establishing a setting that will strand you out into the small town of Oregon and the community who is scared of the unknown events. The focus of story driven scares, character centered sequences, and using your imagination to paint the antagonist work very well and help establish a realistic horror that can be appreciated in the sea of cheesy movies that this genre sometimes gets. And the acting is by far the strongest point for me with talent from the younger star really blowing my mind at how well he could bring so much to this character. However, by taking this approach, Antlers scare factor is a bit diluted from the traditional sense and has a lot of elements that get in the way of a masterpiece scare flick they were going for. Pacing and predictability sort of dilute things, and the carnage may be more disgusting than creepy given the response of a few patrons in my showing. The two biggest limitations of the film though are the limited backstories/character development and little time with the antagonist that will be the most disheartening to many I think. It seems like this movie was incomplete to me and so I can’t say that I’m surprised that with the delays, things suffered in the final cut. Overall, this movie is probably best watched at home with a theater like room, and I would give the film:
Drama/Horror/Mystery: 6.5
Movie Overall: 5.5